HC refuses to quash corruption charges in Rs. 40.83-lakh JDA contract case

21/11/2026
image



JAMMU, Nov 20: The High Court of Jammu and Kashmir and Ladakh has refused to quash corruption and criminal conspiracy charges against former Jammu Development Authority (JDA) Executive Engineer Ashok Kumar Gandotra and others in an alleged irregular allotment of a Rs. 40.83-lakh renovation contract without inviting tenders.
Justice Sanjay Dhar dismissed the petition challenging the chargesheet arising out of FIR No. 10/2020 registered by the Anti-Corruption Bureau (ACB), Jammu, observing that the manner in which the contract was awarded prima facie indicated favouritism, nepotism and abuse of official position.
The case relates to renovation and interior works at the JDA office complex at Vikas Bhawan, Rail Head Complex, Jammu, in 2011.
According to the prosecution, the then Vice Chairman of JDA had initially approved installation of 10 two-ton air conditioners and allied electrical works through competitive bidding. M/s Lumen Engineers emerged as the lowest bidder (L1), but the tender process was subsequently cancelled on April 8, 2011.
The prosecution alleged that the scope of work was later expanded to include renovation and interior works, and the contract was awarded to a private firm on a nomination basis without inviting fresh tenders.
The contract was valued at Rs. 40.83 lakh, of which Rs. 40.53 lakh was released to the contractor. The ACB alleged that the decision was taken in connivance with certain officials to extend undue benefits to the selected firm.
The investigation also assessed an alleged loss of Rs. 1,46,828 to the government exchequer after accounting for certain deductions.
Senior Advocate Rahul Pant, assisted by Advocate Aniruddh Sharma, appearing for the petitioners, argued that the work was specialised in nature and that no financial loss had been caused to the government. The defence also questioned the calculations adopted by the investigating agency for assessing the alleged loss.
Additional Advocate General Raman Sharma, assisted by Advocate Saliqa Sheikh, appeared for the ACB and opposed the petition.
After examining the material, Justice Dhar observed that the nature of the renovation and air-conditioning work did not justify dispensing with competitive bidding, as other experienced and appropriately licensed contractors could also have undertaken the project.
The Court observed that public authorities cannot exercise their discretion arbitrarily while awarding government contracts and are required to ensure transparency, open competition and equal opportunities for eligible contractors.
Referring to the Supreme Court judgment in Neera Yadav versus CBI, the High Court observed that criminal misconduct by a public servant is not restricted to cases where the official personally obtains financial benefits. Misuse of official position to confer an undue pecuniary advantage upon a third party can also attract criminal liability.
On the question of alleged financial loss, the Court held that disputes regarding calculations and the applicability of CPWD rates involved technical issues that could be examined during the trial through expert evidence.
Justice Dhar observed that the High Court could not conduct a mini-trial or adjudicate disputed questions of evidence while examining a challenge to an order framing charges.
Finding sufficient material to proceed against the accused, the Court dismissed the petition, leaving the charges framed by the Special Judge Anti-Corruption, Jammu, intact.
The judgment was pronounced on November 19, 2026, paving the way for continuation of the trial.

Share This Story


Comment On This Story

 

Photo Gallery

  
BSE Sensex
NSE Nifty